THE "WAIT THIS ISN'T BUTTER?" ONE: MIYOKO'S CREAMERY EUROPEAN STYLE BUTTER ($6.89)
Wild Elements' producer Whitney Beer-Kerr calls this best-selling option "a legit solid loaf of butter—and sooo yummy!" Its ingredients include sunflower oil and cashew milk, which (fun fact) are both great for your skin!
THE GOURMET ONE: MONTY'S PLANT-BASED BUTTER ($8.79)
Created by trained chef Lauren Montgomery, this small-batch butter is so coveted by foodies that it sells out pretty fast—but we've had luck scoring it on Instacart. It's made with just 4 ingredients, including a generous swirl of sea salt.
THE NUT-FREE SAVIOR: PLAIN JANE LUV BUTTER ($7)
Pea protein for strength? Check. Vitamin A extract for an immune boost? Check. Beet-based lactic acid? Check. Nuts of any kind? Nope! Yay!
THE SWEET ONE: OMG COOKIE BUTTER BY KRONA ($35)
Made with antioxidant-rich goji berries, plus cinnamon (which helps curb inflammation) and coconut, this butter is packed with plant protein but tastes like you stole some batter from the kitchen.